A Review of Annotated Edition
Well Steven or should I say Al or should I say to both of you... Congratulations on a humorous story steeped in metafiction! The footnotes are very funny. I never knew J. Edgar Hoover didn't invent the vacuum cleaner. And all this time the picture I have of him hanging on my bedroom wall next to Derwood Kirby was all for nothing. I guess you learn something new every day.
When I saw Mobius strip in the first sentence I said, "Good! Finally a story with nudity! But who is Mobius?"
I am not sure what to say other than it is a very good and funny story. You really need to get your alter ego on the same page though unless you wish to expand it then you and your alter ego must agree to disagree.
This was a very creative exercize in exercizing your creativity. Good job!
I hope this has helped...
Tom
Other Reviews by talfier1@comcast.net
37
-
Mr. Wheeler's story is the start to a longer work. The beginning seemed more like it was part of her imagination than the supernatural. I am not sure I see the supernatural there at all.
The second part merely hints at the possibility of the supernatural rather than anything concrete.
I think the doll needs to be more of a character. Then you will really be going closer to...
Mr. Wheeler's story is the start to a longer work. The beginning seemed more like it was part of her imagination than the supernatural. I am not sure I see the supernatural there at all.
The second part merely hints at the possibility of the supernatural rather than anything concrete.
I think the doll needs to be more of a character. Then you will really be going closer to the edge of reality. So far all I can see is that you are talking more about her imagination and maybe wish fulfillment than the supernatural.
I am not sure if the businessman would react like that if that was a real situation. Maybe he would be scared but I am not sure he would worry about his expensive clothes if she is being attacked or followed like that.
The old guy seems more like a guy from central casting. He seems like more like a humorous character in a "Twilight Zone" episode than a strong, original character.
There are some grammatical issues also.
When emphasizing words you do not need to put them in all caps.
The police not going to "that area of town" for a domestic disturbance doesn't seem like it is based in reality. Police are obligated to go there especially for a domestic disturbance. All areas of a city are covered in some way by a police department whether it is in a local, county, or state jurisdiction.
I hope this has helped.
Tom
read
-
Mr. Garry's story is a good start to a longer work. I think that the story could go deeper into the main character's disturbed mind. Maybe include an internal monologue rant in his apartment. I am not sure if there is a chance for "hope" in his mind if he is killing like a machine or puppet especially if he is killing his friends and relatives. If there is a concept of right...
Mr. Garry's story is a good start to a longer work. I think that the story could go deeper into the main character's disturbed mind. Maybe include an internal monologue rant in his apartment. I am not sure if there is a chance for "hope" in his mind if he is killing like a machine or puppet especially if he is killing his friends and relatives. If there is a concept of right and wrong in his mind then I think that he would not want to kill his friends. He must feel obligated from the start and really not question "his reality". He would probably be more paranoid or feel an obligation to kill rather than having hope through the questioning of right and wrong. I guess I feel as though he is past that stage. People who are experiencing a mental breakdown like this seem to have no idea that they are committing the crimes. If they do realize that they are committing crimes, it seems as though they are more interested in "their concept of reality being right" than hoping they will stop killing or hoping that they will "stop listening to the voices that tell them to kill". In their mind, their concept of reality is manifested through actions. I see a disparity between the two at this point.
There are some mistakes with grammar and such that should be addressed.
What caused the "acrid wisps of smoke"? The gun? If so, is "acrid" the proper word? The smell of gunpowder doesn't seem acrid to me. It has a smoother smell like smokey salt or something like that. The smoke from a gun is almost in a way like the smell of gasoline. Both have an odd but interesting odor even though they do not smell the same. I am not sure if they are "acrid" though. I would use more of a descriptive voice than a "judgemental" word on the smell itself.
Anyway, I would study some people who have had similar problems. Watch the shows on those who have had mental problems and have been mass murderers. I am sure you will see people who are convinced of their plight no matter how absurd it may seem to you and I. Also, psychopaths have no guilt. The only guilt they have comes after they have been caught. Then the remorse is not for the victims but for their own stupidity resulting from their errors after being caught by the police.
Stalkers at times are so wrapped up in their world that you cannot see any hope in their ways. Their logic seems skewed to say the least. John Lennon's stalker wanted to take over and be John Lennon. He thought by killing John Lennon he would be recognized as John Lennon. I know that this character is not a stalker per se, but there are some similarities. The urge to kill is there. The "Son of Sam" believed that his dog was telling him to kill. This seems illogical to us but to him it was real enough for him to commit the crimes. I think the criminal mind is more complex than is being presented here. I would do more research on mass murderers and specifically those who have experienced a nervous breakdown.
I hope this has helped.
Tom
read
-
I have no problem with experimental works but this seems more like a filmic, "Burgess-esque" character study than a story. I may be wrong but I got very little "story" from your submission. The writing obviously is unique in approach but there is little use in the way of explaining your little verbal "quirks".
There are some punctuation errors and a few other problems from...
I have no problem with experimental works but this seems more like a filmic, "Burgess-esque" character study than a story. I may be wrong but I got very little "story" from your submission. The writing obviously is unique in approach but there is little use in the way of explaining your little verbal "quirks".
There are some punctuation errors and a few other problems from a technical standpoint.
I really don't get any feeling of anything for the characters. As I said before it is more about character description than anything else. There are references to people but not much else other than the narrator stating if there is love or hate for another character.
I am not sure if this has helped.
Tom
read
+ more reviews
