Review of: Crocodile Tears 

reviewed by rmahler on 11/29/2008
Credited Review
rmahler
Almost There Credited Review
Okay, this review is going to seem almost contradictory, but here goes...Sometimes yout don't have enough faith in our dialogue. You could strip away the italics and quotes and underlines and parentheticals in almost every instance and the script would be cleaner, and it would help the flow. You HAVE TO trust the intelligence of your reader to get it sometimes. The flip side of that is that you rely very heavily on dialog, forgetting that screenplays are a visual medium. Don't get me wrong. Some of your dialog is very clever, and worthy of a feature film, but often this script is just too talky. You need to find ways to make this script more visual. Also, you need to help the reader by making the characters more distinct. If I always have to look at the name to know who's speaking, that means your characters are running together. You have some very good ideas here, a decent set of characters, but often you sink into cliche and many of your scenes indicate that you can rise above that. Work on a rewrite (I know how hard that is, believe me) and bring this up to the next level.

Other Reviews by rmahler 98

  • A review of Blackout.com
    by rmahler on 12/19/2008
    This was an interesting concept that made for a good read. I think the dialog needed work to make it more natural and you might want to think of more ways to make the script more visual and less dialog driven, but the concept itself is solid. I'm not sure that I understand what you were trying to accomplish with the ending on the bus though. Why does Jamal fake his death?... read
  • by rmahler on 12/13/2008
    Overall, this was a well-wrought script. The goal is clear cut from the start and the obstacles are well constructed for the protagonist to overcome. One minor mistake is that you attribute Ode to Joy to Bach (it's from Beethoven's 9th). I do have a few things that I think need addressing. First of all, I think you set up a very good conflict for Albert, but in a way he... read
  • A review of OLD ROTHBERGHIAN
    by rmahler on 12/04/2008
    I applaud you for your valiant effort to write in what is obviously not your native language. I could not do the same. However, the fact that I could tell that it was not your native language means that it got in the way of my enjoyment of your story. You should seriously consider get a screenplay editor to read and edit your script to make it more proper English. Your... read
+ more reviews