Review of: Gunfighter's Waltz 

reviewed by minxproductions on 05/09/2005
An interesting piece
Unlike anything I've seen on the site before and most definitely an interesting historical piece that succeeds in commenting on the times and the futileness of the event itself. I was both refreshed and frustrated by this film. It was well shot, very authentic, had excellent framing, camera movement and focus pulls. It retained my attention from beginning to end and I was interested in the story you had to tell. However, for me, it took too long to start and finish. I'm not sure of the timing, but it felt as if approximately 1 minute passed before the first image came on screen. Although information needs to be communicated, I felt this could have been much shorter, or ultimately better over footage (to set up the scene). I also felt the scenes describing the characters' fate could have been shorter, while still successfully communicating the essence of the film. A technically very proficient film, great cinematography, fantastic effects and ultimately compelling.

Other Reviews by minxproductions 52

  • A review of The Dinner Party
    by minxproductions on 09/12/2005
    You seem to have experienced a lot of problems making the short, but as a viewer I respond to what I see and hear, without the knowledge that your production notes provide. Your script came across as general chit-chatter and has a lot of irrelevant dialogue. While this may reflect real life it is not interesting to watch. It took quite some time to reach the first reveal, then... read
  • A review of Keepsake
    by minxproductions on 09/12/2005
    I loved this little tale. A very interesting take on abuse. I thought the script was very well written, and that the direction, cinematography and editing only enhanced it further. Obviously you had a little funding to shoot on 16mm, which you have used to add to the atmosphere of the short. I found a few of the shot choices and transitions between WS and CU with the butcher... read
  • A review of When Hope Is Helpless
    by minxproductions on 09/12/2005
    I'm really not sure how to review this because I'm not confident I get what you were trying to do. If your friend really does have cancer (as the documentary genre seems to indicate) then it really is a tragic story. But your synopsis, as well as the style of the production, makes it seem almost comical - which makes me feel really insensitive if the story is indeed true. If... read
+ more reviews