Review of: The Doll (2nd Draft) 

reviewed by JLVDP on 12/09/2011
Credited Review
JLVDP
Atmosfear ? Credited Review
I like this type of very short stories built around a classic horror theme. I think this story can become more interesting with more work on both characters and atmosphere. I believe that with a more thoughtful choice of words, the amosphere can be made more interesting. The story needn't be much longer but needs reworking. That takes time and many attempts. At this time the story is still rough and obvious. The moment the evil comes could be delivered less obviously. The character of the girl needs work so that the reader can care more for her. At the moment she witnesses the story and allows us to see it through her eyes but we don't get to actually feel for her.

More work needed, but this story will work.

Other Reviews by JLVDP 28

  • A review of Till Death Do Us Part
    by JLVDP on 12/21/2011
    A film is always worth respect because it requires so much work. It is always difficult to pull through a project a bit too big. This film is unfortunately too amateurish. The framing is not always good, the cutting inadequate, the production values minimal. The story itself would have worked better had it been trimmed and further reworked. The actors do their best and the... read
  • A review of one day
    by JLVDP on 12/10/2011
    This is a very nice and/but very short audiovisual piece. I write 'but' because it feels like an intro in the end. The end could be the starting point of a true story, not just the evocation of a moment as One Day is. I let myself imagine the difficulties the protagonists can encounter by trying to meet again. Because I believe we want them to meet again. The film is touching,... read
  • A review of Neggy Meets Sammy
    by JLVDP on 12/09/2011
    I like the overall message of this piece. But I am less comfortable with the way it is put together. First, the non-stop voice over makes it difficult to get in the story. The redundancy in the text can be interesting but here, combined with the relatively lowly interesting visuals, it makes the whole short painful to go through. The redundancy is of course related to the theme... read
+ more reviews