Review of: LOST AT SEA 

reviewed by judylewis on 02/27/2004
Credited Review
judylewis
Brainy and the Band Credited Review
This is an old-fashioned love story with some very funny set pieces in it. For the most part, the story elements are neatly interwoven and elements are carefully set up to pay off later. Some of the characters' voices are uneven, but generally the older people sound like people of their generation, the aging hippies sound like aging hippies and the 80s rock band sounds like an aging rock band. I'd like to see more of Paul with Goth Violet, maybe chronologically rather than via flashback. I'd like to see Paul interact with a groupie to learn that he doesn't like them (not just hear about it). Most of the dialog is well thought out, but some is too "on the nose." In places you might find fresher ways of saying things, eg, Carol's heartfelt speech at the end could be more specific, less direct, less Hallmark card. Paul's grouchy dad, Helmut & Rudy are all individuals. Elsa should appear earlier, perhaps as Violet's teacher. There is a plot: boy meets girl, boy loses girl, but it's also a story about learning to risk loving someone. The one thing that isn't resolved is Paul's career. He should be planning to go to college, become a gardener or songwriter--after Tahiti of course. Good visuals: cemetery, yacht, band, garden, raft.

Other Reviews by judylewis 117

  • A review of The 13th Christmas
    by judylewis on 09/10/2004
    THE 13th CHRISTMAS abounds with vivid action scenes and colorful characters. Orson makes an adventure-filled trip to find the gate to the North Pole. The story seems muddy, with too many characters and destinations. Integrate these elements into the script, so we hear about Twink and Magellan earlier, and they won't seem like afterthoughts. The rich plot is complicated and... read
  • A review of Dogman
    by judylewis on 06/28/2004
    The troubled eponymous main character immediately earns our empathy. The plot twists are somewhat predictable and we can guess that Walt & Rina share culpability from the judge's hints. Some elements are confusing: Why is the judge suspicious? Wouldn't an autopsy reveal the actual cause of the child's death? Morgan is sympathetic, Walt is hateful. Rina's character is a bit... read
  • A review of The Ark
    by judylewis on 06/27/2004
    A fast read with good visuals and characters we care about. The story suffers sometimes from preachy dialog that spells out many of script's themes. The scenes with Gentor in particular, are too on-the-nose. "The trust we have for each other is all we have that stands between us and the darkness outside." Sometimes the action is sufficient (the anarchist scenes are terrific),... read
+ more reviews