Review of: The Hole 

reviewed by 10pagesaday on 11/21/2011
Credited Review
Ghosts of Alcatraz Credited Review

CONCEPT: the thought of a prison ghost intrigued me.


VIC SOLO was a recovering drug addicted low life with a mysterious past. I didn't get a feel for him. I mean what made him go to drugs? How did a low life hook up with a single mom? And his past was life was confusing. Did he kill them just get money for drugs? Did I miss it? I didn't understand the connection between him and Mad Dog.

HELEN was a weak female character. What single mom would date an ex-drug addict? We didn't know her attraction to him and why she would move cross country with him.

MAD DOG, there wasn't much to him. He just wanted freedom even though we don't get to know on how he would attain it.

ALEX was the bright spot. Video game kid who knows about ghosts.

DIALOGUE: was precise but felt like you were telling us what was going to happen instead of showing us. I think you could be a little more subtle.

STORY was confusing. As of now I'm thinking that Vic was really Peter Swain who kills his family but then takes a prisoner's identity? If that's right then it doesn't make any sense to me.

OVERALL, i like the fact that you have minimal characters. I like that your dialogue isn't clunky but yet needs more sparkle. I like Alex but other than him the other characters aren't likable. Add more depth and believability to your characters and clear up the plot of the story a bit. Nothing personal it's just my two cents.

Other Reviews by 10pagesaday 78

  • A review of Love, Inc.
    by 10pagesaday on 12/31/2013
    The first couple of pages and I thought this was too close to Hitch but by the end you added some real nice twists. The characters were pretty good. Dylan was the serious, strictly business type and the other lover was Rufus who was totally opposite in every way imaginable. Good deal. My only problem was Jackie she seemed kind of one dimensional. Besides her foul language... read
  • by 10pagesaday on 11/18/2013
    Your concept has been overdone but more so in comedy than drama so that's a good thing. Your characters are standard fare. You need to spice them up a bit more. Did Darren have a dream as a kid other than moving? What does he like to do? For instance, I'm gonna assume you seen The Wire. Webey was a stone cold killer but he loved fish aquariums. Stringer Bell was the educated... read
  • by 10pagesaday on 10/14/2013
    At first glance this seemed to be the run of the mill time traveling story but I think you added a few ingredients to make it somewhat different. You added a Benjamin Button and a little of Indiana Jones type of effect. The characters didn't really stand out to me. Tom and Arianna were kind of dull. However, Mr. Jones and Reinhard were cool and had an aura of mystery. I think... read
+ more reviews