Review of: Rock Bottom
reviewed by dunphoid on 05/19/2010
Good Creepy Read
I enjoyed this. It was very creepy. I felt claustrophobic thanks to the literally in-your-face approach from the cameramen. I think you could go further with these cameramen. How about a camera lens attack somewhere in the story - literally having camera lenses battering someone to death (the wife prior to losing her eyes?). I'm thinking of that old chiller from the sixties (British I think) where you see killing from the point of view of the camera man - can't remember the title sorry.
Overall your dialogue was good. I suggest changes to the following though:
“Well sir my wife and I work hard. We have never done anything except abide by the rules given to us by society..." etc
This was much too stilted to make me feel like I could identify with this guy. Over the course of the story I did identify with him, but right here I think he could sound much more natural...perhaps bumbling.
“Can this day get any stranger,” Richard questions himself?
This is a bit on-the-nose for me. I would suggest you cut it out since we've already aware of how strange things are without needing it spelt out.
“You have taken everything from me. I have nothing left,”
Again, I'd cut this out. We've seen the dead wife, so having Richard state the obvious is overkill for me.
“No one would watch this sick disgusting show,”
In the circumstances, perhaps he'd not be of the mindset to have an opinion about the show. I'd be more like "Sick bastards! Graaagh!" and charging at the suit to smash his face in! :o)
Having the people disappear in a ball of fire didn't do it for me. I'd prefer to see them quietly pack up their gear and leave. Perhaps a neighbour could arrive and scream. A 'realistic' ending is more startling and chilling for me personally.
Cool story. Very Twilight Zone. The HIV bit was so outrageous (was it intended to be black humour) that I chuckled.
The forty year old man as the kid was a bit unbelievable. He is very creepy but I'd prefer to see a real kid in that role, just for the sake of keeping things a bit believable.
Well done. As a horror fan I lapped your story up.
Other Reviews by dunphoid 109
A review of Smarter Than A Smartphoneby dunphoid on 05/20/2013Nice slick writing and good dialogue that I could clearly imagine being said. The smugness of the narrator from start to finish was fun. I saw faint flashes of 'The Dude' from The Big Lebowski in my mind as I read -- just this laid back guy in an environment which seems alien to him, who hardly ever gets ruffled. I could get a real sense of John getting very wound up, and... read
A review of Tom and The Sunday Afternoon Raceby dunphoid on 05/20/2013Fun story that brightened my day. Very nice location description in opening paragraph subtly interwoven with history. For the hero the use of "smallish" to describe him didn't read right to me. Maybe give a sense of his small size/proportion compared to the chair he's sat on or the table he's sat at? By the same token, tallish seemed okay for Rocky (the bad guy!). "Smallish"... read
A review of Reviewing Rachelby dunphoid on 05/19/2013I enjoyed Reviewing Rachel. A neat twist at the end reminiscent of The Ring-type curses that get passed on and on…always good chilling territory. The story taps into human greed and lies in its approach to plagiarism, which gives the story a bit more substance than a mere curse-passed-on-chain story. It's not until later in the story I noticed the "aged casement windows" and... read