reviewed by tom goldsmith on 01/18/2004
tom goldsmith
it's hard for me to take a inking to this...
I just had this conscious feeling all the time that I had read or written this same material before. I'm not saying it's ripped off anything because it'shighly original. It's just I, myself had these same ideas.However, this is a very well written and eventful script. I enjoyed the characters and it was a niceaspect to see the central story set in the Gulf War and the characters are overall well done.The Iragi references seem alittle controversial to be made at the moment however but hey, we shouldn't be worrying about uptight Hollywood bosses with reputations to keepAt the end, I felt it was a tad too long, to just cut the loose edges would be my suggestion.But well done and good luck.
NOTE: This review does not factor into the site rankings.

Other Reviews by tom goldsmith 15

  • A review of Dog Given Rights
    by tom goldsmith on 01/21/2004
    but is a tad too long and frustrates. I watched and was extremely amused at the concept and the fact that all these humans were dressed in make up na d fur.Some scenes are great, early on it is stunning, but I feel in the later scenes, you are just reproducing a lot of the dialogue and conversatiuon from the earlier scenes.I have to saay, I'm not a big fan of the musical but... read
  • A review of The Salesman
    by tom goldsmith on 01/15/2004
    some of threviews it's got on this site make it out to be comparable to The Music Box. It;s not. But then, it's not bad either. The argument could of been extended, there was no real point and the end was unfulfilling, but still, I watched with a certain thing in my head urging me to watch on.
  • A review of The Knocking
    by tom goldsmith on 01/12/2004
    This seems to be a pointless waste of time. Most of it could have been over black with white titles for the majority of the film, other than short bursts where people answer the door.I try to be as positive as I can in reviews but watching this was dull. I think it would work well as a short story. I honestly think it would , but a short film seems a pointless waste of time... read
+ more reviews