Review of: (Miss Kitty) Amy 

reviewed by AlCielo on 07/21/2011
AlCielo
Lament for Amy
Even for an Elmer Lang film, this is an unusually complex fusion of reality, re-enactment, and imagination. The tension between empathy (from the images of Amy) and distancing (largely from the narrator's comments) reminds me a little of Bunuel's "Land without Bread." Part sermon, part witnessing (but ultimately neither), "Miss Kitty" invites us to reflect on the unknowability of other people, and of life itself. The one certainty seems to be that we are drawn (both as filmmakers and as film viewers) to speculate on our ability to know things whenever we're confronted with something from outside our familiar bubbles. There's a tragic momentum of decline--an inertia of motion from falling out a window--from the artist who knew (or thought he knew) her, to the filmmaker, who seeks to know her, to the druggies in the park, who know of her, but don't care much. The key, as I interpret the film, is not so much to know or to seek to know, as it is to empathize, without superimposing our own comfortable, shopworn perspectives ("things you wouldn't let your daughter do"). My only suggestion, in the event of a re-edit, would be to include more footage (maybe still photos if necessary) of Amy herself, particularly in the final sections.

Other Reviews by AlCielo 299

  • A review of Chase the Night
    by AlCielo on 07/25/2013
    "Chase the Night" is a taut character-driven action story with an important theme. My major reservations about this draft are at the deepest level of structure (how everything fits together and why). The only essential task a writer has is to maintain the audience's attention for the duration of the viewing (or reading). If the audience isn't immersed in the story, no amount... read
  • A review of Unseen
    by AlCielo on 03/13/2013
    "Unseen" is based on a strong premise--a young man hounded by guilt for his brother's kidnapping seeks revenge. Having such a clear, important concept is critical--if the basis for the story is unaffecting, then it doesn't matter how well written the screenplay is. My goal here is to help you develop the strengths of your premise. To do that, I'm going to focus on weaknesses... read
  • by AlCielo on 06/27/2012
    Combining Dante and Leone is a gutsy choice, but not necessarily a futile one (filming the Inferno would be another matter). The Inferno is first and foremost a quest / journey (un cammin) and the spaghetti western protagonists normally undertake a quest. Both Dante and Leone present a larger-than-life world (but one that depicts our own with accuracy and restraint). In this... read
+ more reviews