Review of: Lost Son 

reviewed by murraybuesst on 08/30/2005
Credited Review
murraybuesst
Lost and found... Credited Review
The premise of LOST SON is unusual, and very interesting. A young boy experiences flashbacks from a past life, as a naval pilot in World War II. His concerned mother must overcome her own scepticism - and that of their family - if she is to help him.

I enjoyed reading the script, not least for its examplary screenplay style, which made me extremely jealous because - damn it! - it was flawless. The scenes immaculately handled, the structure very good, and (more jealousy) it is superbly clear throughout - I never once was unsure who anyone was or what was going on.

For what they're worth, my observations are:

- I found the tension between Devany and Eric a little forced. Whilst I perfectly understood that Eric might easily react the way he does at Devany's behaviour, deep down I didn't really know why. That's to say that I felt I wasn't gaining any insights into his character (in contrast, for example, to his mother, who came alive for me and was entirely convincing) - I was simply being told his reaction.

- I was a little unhappy that Taylor's regressions were initially limited to dreams, but then seemed to be possible while he was awake (and this was essential at the end). I can't help feeling the logic of this needs to be made watertight if it is not to be subconsciously jarring.

- There's very, very little in the way of subtext in the dialogue. I was very aware that throughout the screenplay everyone expresses, very cogently, exactly what they feel about things. The result is that there is precious little for the reader to speculate about. Given the subject matter, I wonder if there could be a little more ambiguity.

But all in all, a stimulating read. And magnificent clarity!

Other Reviews by murraybuesst 22

  • by murraybuesst on 08/01/2007
    I romped through this screenplay, and was laughing from the first page. From reading the synopsis, I wondered whether this was going to be neat idea rather crassly executed, but in fact it was both smart and extremely witty from beginning to end. And superbly structured, paced, and, well ... goddam it! So my few observations are really only minor points. First, I wonder... read
  • A review of Voice Over
    by murraybuesst on 08/05/2005
    I loved this. The dialogue is just gorgeous - hugely funny, whilst never once breaking character to get a laugh. I genuinely cared about the characters. And I don't think there was a single scene that did what I thought it was going to. Really, really good writing. Structurally, I wondered whether it was a little front heavy. I suspect Mary-Ann should come out of the... read
  • by murraybuesst on 08/03/2005
    You have to take your hat off to a script that calls for 160,000 extras. Against such a huge canvas, the story had better be a strong one. And a woman disguising herself as a man to fight in the civil war has plenty of potential. But as it stands, I feel that this screenplay does not really deliver. I suspect that the problem grows out of the initial construction. It opens... read
+ more reviews