Review of: Unconditional 

reviewed by bigheadx on 03/12/2012
Credited Review
Love my dog, love me? Credited Review
This is a cute, extremely brief story with a twist that is a slight surprise. As a writing exercise, this reader admires your effort. But at the basic story level, what is so unusual about an older, unattractive man having a young, much admired dog? The repetition of reactions from strangers seem merely in place so as to "pay off" and exaggerate the twist. Even an adolescent reader might feel manipulated.
That said, in this reader's opinion, the writing is clean, colorful, and devoid of mistakes (but, why so many semi-colons? many are inappropriate and/or unnecessary).
Nice job!

Other Reviews by bigheadx 256

  • A review of The Hard Choice
    by bigheadx on 01/13/2012
    "Meandering" came to this reader's mind as he read this interesting but occasionally confusing story. In vignettes, we learn about this young man's past and present - family, girlfriends, boyfriends. Unfortunately, considering its length, we come away knowing very little because the story drifts, much like its main character drifts from scene to scene, memory to memory. If... read
  • A review of Belted
    by bigheadx on 06/22/2011
    Thank you for the opportunity to read this brief short story. Except in some cases (specifics below), the writing is competent and descriptive but, in this reader's opinion, ~525 words are not enough to fully convey the nature of the character's world, the character himself, or the reasons for his predicament. Still, it is an imaginative tale if only because it has taken... read
  • by bigheadx on 06/21/2011
    Thank you for the opportunity to read this amusing short story. Its use of a well-known film character indicates it is more a writing exercise than a publishable work, but that doesn't diminish the imagination and humor it contains. There are some punctuation, grammar, and format issues that need to be addressed (specifics below). While this reader feels the concept was a... read
+ more reviews