Review of: Winding River 

reviewed by neilg117 on 11/25/2009
neilg117
Needs to be a bit quicker
I thought this was OK, especially given the constraints of making this in such a short space of time.

Positives for me were some of the shot selections. I particularly liked your willingness to use long shots. This adds a lot to your images as often the park looked gorgeous. The camera on its side on the floor also was an interesting and quirky choice. On the whole the photography is well composed and well lit.

Key downside on display here really is the pacing. There really isn't enough material to justify the running time. Most of the pre-amble in the park could be cut. And losing a few shots (or trimming the duration of the shots you have) would have given the chase a lot more energy.

But as a class exercise there are a lot of positives here. You've told a story in images alone - and because of this it is impressively cinematic. Good luck.

Other Reviews by neilg117 541

  • A review of CE3R
    by neilg117 on 08/03/2010
    This was quite good fun. Film was cleanly shot. Lighting and sound were clean. Editing was slick and pacing was fine. I really liked the Nazi mashed potato and the choice of word "hopefully" at the end. Both made me smile. The only thing that didn't work for me really was the choice of the Nazis as the source of Utopia. Whilst watching it I couldn't quite work out why... read
  • Fun Non Credited Review
    A review of A Spill
    by neilg117 on 11/27/2009
    This is a fun short movie. It looks great and the fact you've told the story in visuals makes this feel like a piece of cinema. The story is capably plotted. You set-up the premise efficiently and move quickly to the fun gag at the end. The actual punchline made me smile. It works quite well. Don't have too much constructive too say. Camera and lighting are fine. The... read
  • A review of Christmas Cookies
    by neilg117 on 03/27/2009
    I enjoyed much of this short film. It is nicely shot. I loved the saturated colour with all the red and the slight hue to the photography. It all adds to the commercial feel to the piece. The facial expressions of the mother were particularly fun. Visually the "perfect" family is well conceived and presented concisely back to the viewer. Only downside really was a lack... read
+ more reviews