Review of: Mr. Christian 

reviewed by rjsilva on 03/23/2011
Credited Review
rjsilva
One of my Favorites Credited Review
I must have started to read this a half dozen times and stopped. Only when I settled in for a good read, was I not able to put it down and it quickly became one of my favorites. It wasn't because the beginning was badly written, it isn't. I just had to be in the mood for this subject matter and that might be what hurts it the most but I think the entire SP is brilliant.

Here are a couple of minor issues I had;

P7 Adams’ dialogue pretty sure every sailor has heard of the Bounty, consider revising.

P8 Adams’ dialogue doesn’t sound natural, consider revising.

P11 second time you’ve underlined something, it’s distracting and unnecessary.

P14 McCoy’s dialogue “BUT THANKS?” doesn’t make sense.

P15 Minarii’s dialogue is really bad. I half expected they would all be sitting around singing kumbaya in the next scene. Please consider revising.

P35 Thursday October is getting on my nerves, consider revising to just October or something.

P60 should be formatted as a SERIES OF SHOTS

P108 formatting this scene as a flashback is confusing, consider revising.

If I were reading this as a professional, I would definately suggest someone take a closer look at it. Nicely done.

Good Luck,
Ron

Other Reviews by rjsilva 52

  • A review of The Zombie Hunters
    by rjsilva on 02/07/2013
    John, I’ve got to tell you, I was a little giddy at first, getting an actual request for a read but now I’m thinking, holy crap, I actually have to a really good job with this one. So, let’s start right away with your posted synopsis. The very first thing people see other than a title page is usually a Logline and Synopsis. If these items have errors, then a reader might think... read
  • A review of Starry Night
    by rjsilva on 12/11/2012
    Sablezena, congratulations on completing “Starry Night”. Finishing a SP is not an easy thing to do and putting it on a site like Triggerstreet for everyone to rip it to shreds takes a massive amount of courage but you did it. First off, I’d like to say how much I like the concept but the flow of the story is constantly interrupted and all of the errors just kill the thing... read
  • A review of Mountain (V2)
    by rjsilva on 05/06/2012
    Lizz-Ayn thanks for posting MOUNTAIN. As a ver2, I don’t think there’ll be anything I can add but I’ll make some suggestions anyway. PAGES 1-10 Consider changing the line “so is this” to “more important than this?” Same thing just sounds less petty. The words making a big show of read as condescending and I don’t think Tessa means it to be. Try to avoid yes/no dialogue when... read
+ more reviews