reviewed by **DELETED ACCOUNT** on 12/03/2004
I happened upon this script by pure accident, and since I'm considering a story about a soldier dealing with PTSD, I was very interested to read it. The synopsis is engaging, so I started to read. First, let me say that I read it cover to cover in 2 sittings. It was engaging and had great story elements. The dialogue was good, and could stand a tiny bit of tightening. I am of the belief that dialogue should sound as if it's the most interesting way to say anything. The characters were good, but the duality of Eileen's role (her conflict being internal) could have been stronger. I think there's an underlying structural weakness in that the audience has no real hint at the grim reality of her true weakness. We assume for too long that it's just standard POW problems. If there was some stronger hint that there was something more to her story earlier, you would have me wondering and more engaged. As it is, I felt a lull about 50 pages (don't recall exact page count). The twist is good and it makes for a truly bittersweet resolution. I'm a pretty macho guy and I was nearly crying at the end. I have more to say, but am running out of room....that's a good sign.
NOTE: This review does not factor into the site rankings.

Other Reviews by **DELETED ACCOUNT** 3429

  • A review of Angels (rev)
    by **DELETED ACCOUNT** on 10/29/2014
    Heya David, long time no see. This is the first time I've ever done a non free will review of a script you've posted. I'll do my best to justify using up your credits. :p I read and reviewed "Time Rift" over two years, and your descriptions are the element of that script that stand out most vividly in my memory. I'll say now what I expect I said then; they're short and punchy... read
  • A review of Wait for Morning
    by **DELETED ACCOUNT** on 10/18/2014
    Hi Paul, “Wait for Morning” is an engaging family drama. Overall, it's a polished draft, with good character development, believable moments, and great dialogue. In terms of the structure/story elements, the plot points follow Eric, when he leaves home, his accident, returning home, and his peace with Liv. Consider drawing out Finn's turning points more. Cookie's subplot... read
  • A review of Are we you?
    by **DELETED ACCOUNT** on 10/11/2014
    This review is going to be all about dialogue. I've got to say, I never realized how negatively a screenplay can be impacted when just one component isn't in the box. Because "Are We You?" really ought to have everything in the world going for it. It's a dynamic premise, the characters are put through the ringer, and you're dealing with really interesting subject matter (9/11... read
+ more reviews