Review of: Elsie White's Will 

reviewed by mnjones on 11/29/2010
Credited Review
mnjones
Putting Elsie to Rest Credited Review
The writer's strong feelings for the events in this story are apparent, but those feelings are not communicated in such a way as to arouse the same feeling in the reader. Much of the dialogue is more speechifying than conversational. There are qute a few typos and misplaced or omitted punctuation. Some of the sentences, as contructed, are unclear. There is a story here that many readers can relate to, but it needs a lot of work. Good luck with it.

A few notes as I read:

Is "chair needed after "recliner"?

"At 75 she had had a good innings"?

"...old ladies would natter each other, other days..." Semicolon instead of comma.

"Have you put the rubbish out dear?" Comma before dear.

"...cuppa tea..." instead of "cup of..." Seems odd in this rather formal narrative.

"...passed away after falling" Needs a period.

"...two brothers had met up..." Wouldn't just "met," without the "up" work better?

"...one of use kids..."

"...as soon as he would be walking into his office..." Wouldn't it be better to write,
...as soon as he walked into...?

Other Reviews by mnjones 381

  • by mnjones on 01/08/2011
    I am a fan of gritty tales with bad guys making life hard for a good guy who who turns the tables on the bad guys by doing something even worse to them. I especially like those written with a fast-paced, light touch that depicts with subtle humor mostly amoral characters. "Henry's Delimma" is one of those. It is fast, sly, and full of the twists reminiscent of Elmore Leonard's... read
  • A review of Saladin Haze
    by mnjones on 12/03/2010
    Strong, gripping, and well-written account of a man at war, a civil war in which he has begun to suspect he may be on the wrong side. I am still puzzled by the disembodied voice that seemed to surround Haze and his men at the roadblock; but the ending is well done, with Haze, who sacrifices his sister so that he can, in her memory and the memory of Anne Frank, "find them"... read
  • A review of Possum and Pizzaiola
    by mnjones on 12/01/2010
    This is a well written account of a dinner shared by folks of very different cultures. There is a very nice scene with some wonderful, very visual descriptions of a dining room and buffet. But what you see in this story is what you get: there's no conflict, mystery, tension, or suspense. But this is a happy story about happy people. How can you complain about that? I do think... read
+ more reviews