Review of: Bathtime 

reviewed by DebraSwan on 02/17/2010
Credited Review
Showers Recommended Credited Review
This is, without a doubt, the most disturbing story I have read here on TS. The bath scene was particularly well done. I was revolted, but couldn't stop reading.
On page 13 the main character 'must have, at some point, fallen asleep.' Somehow that doesn't play out for me. He appears to be in an erotic, engrossing experience that wouldn't lend itself to him just simply falling asleep.
You also moved from past to present tense a lot, sometimes within the same sentence. This made for a confusing read.
Ie: Pg. 1 - 'they snap and squeak as I pulled them on' s/b 'they snap and squeak as I pull them on'
Having said that, I think this is a well written story with a few grammatical errors here and there.
Ie: Pg. 4 - ungentle manly s/b one word 'ungentlemanly'
On Pg. 11 - 'I tried to tell myself I something'; I'm not sure what you meant to say with this sentence.
All in all the story was intriguing and I look forward to reading some of your newer pieces.


Other Reviews by DebraSwan 140

  • A review of Southern Rites
    by DebraSwan on 05/11/2014
    Along with this review I am emailing you the first 40 pages of your script with more extensive notes that I hope you will find useful. This was a cute little yarn with some nice twists. While some of the characters were nicely done - Katie in particular - there were a few more than I think were necessary. This lead to a bit of confusion. While the story was done well, the... read
  • by DebraSwan on 01/03/2014
    The writing style was very interesting and well done. On Pg. 1 you tell the reader that you are repeating something that you havenít yet said. I went back to re-read, thinking I missed something. You might want to clarify this a bit. Pg. 5 The writing in parenthesis took me out of the story. I suggest removing them. This happens again on the next page. Indents are missing... read
  • A review of Dearest
    by DebraSwan on 09/07/2013
    You did a great job drawing the reader into your story quickly. Having said that, it was pretty easy to know where it was going. That isn't a criticism, as much as an observation. The story would benefit from stronger character development. What happened between university and returning to the pub? Why was the summer love so easily forgotten? I was a bit thrown at first... read
+ more reviews