Silver Moon Review
As I read and review screenplays, I like to write what I’m thinking and what I find right away so I’ll just write all the notes as I go through and then have some thoughts at the end:
At page 5, I’m already into this. I am a huge fan on the horror/slasher genre. I love low-budget horror and this starts out just like some of my favorites. I’m excited to keep moving on!
p. 6
KEVIN
Kevin got embarrassed.
-----This is supposed to be Josh’s line
p.12 – Okay, I already love Josh. I can totally see this kid, like many of us probably can. Although these types of kids are assholes, they are actually pretty funny, too. You capture this well.
P29 – After Kevin finds Sam and asks if he is okay, it sounds a little odd for Sam to say, “im fine” and be more worried about Kevin being there than getting viciously attacked. I know he was smoking crack and did want to be seen or what not, but still.
p.62 – the conversation with the group about “what this beast is” is a little overdone in horror scripts. I think you should work on this area and really think about what people would say if they were in a situation like this. Although it may seem like you need “the explanation” in your script I don’t think it’s necessary. I kind of don’t want them to believe it is a werewolf or what not. Being more of an unknown to the group is even more terrifying.
p.66 – REMMY says, “they had an affair, Tim.” That comment seems a little odd. Wouldn’t somebody of their age just say “Emily cheated on Kevin” or something?
-You have a couple of these type of lines in your script that are a little too formal in dialog. People don’t always talk correctly or formally and this adds more to the reality of dialog. Try workin at this a bit, because at times the dialog seems way too “correct”.
p.74 – “never taking her eyes of the monster” should be “off not of”
p.92 – rather than saying first beast and second beast, why don’t you say something that the first is Josh and the second beast is Kevin. Then you can just say Kevin and Josh and we will know they are wolves now and it won’t be as confusing when reading “first and second” beast.
I am a little unsure about the ending… who was lifted off in the helicopter? I guessing that it was somebody who was bit and will turn into a werewolf at the hospital it will be at? Also… when the trains collided I don’t think Josh and Kevin’s bodies would be that well preserved and only have the werewolf battle wounds on them.
I thought your ending was going in a slightly different direction as well. I thought that maybe after the train accident, Emily would be trying to tell the story of werewolves or something and nobody would believe her. They would think that she must be suffering some brain trauma and post tramatic stress. All of the evidence of werewolves existing would be gone due to the fact that the train collision mangled and mashed up everybody on board. Just a thought I had that could be pretty neat.
Overall, I really enjoyed this and thought it was a fun read. Even though it read quite like all other werewolf slashers, I still liked it and thought the build up and final battle between Josh and Eric was worth it. Good payoff there, and I would say a pretty marketable low budget horror flick.
One more thing... I think maybe you could come up with a little better title for this werewolf flick. Silver Moon is remeniscent of all werewolf films and kind of generic. Maybe make it a mix between wolves and cheating lovers? Don't really know a title off the top of my head, but you could get pretty creative with it, and really make it work!
Good Job!
Other Reviews by jjs2028
21
-
Rocket ’78 Review
Nice job with this script. Definitely one of the better scripts on triggerstreet!
I've written down notes as I read and then ended with some final thoughts on the story. Here it all is:
p.2 - EXT. JOHN'S POV -- THE TOWN OF PIRTLESVILLE -- DAY
John sees
Don’t need to say “John sees” we are already at his POV, just tell us what he’s looking at.
p. 4 – No...
Rocket ’78 Review
Nice job with this script. Definitely one of the better scripts on triggerstreet!
I've written down notes as I read and then ended with some final thoughts on the story. Here it all is:
p.2 - EXT. JOHN'S POV -- THE TOWN OF PIRTLESVILLE -- DAY
John sees
Don’t need to say “John sees” we are already at his POV, just tell us what he’s looking at.
p. 4 – No need for (CONT’D). Just turn off auto (cont’d) in settings.
Sometimes your scene headings get very jumbled and it breaks up the action a bit… instead of writing a scene heading and then one line of action/description then another scene heading, just write from one perspective such as just “EXT. EMPTY STRETCH OF ROAD” on p. 7 and 8. Let the director decide when he wants to film the truck or sky car.
p.9 – “JOHN - I gotta go pick up this junk for my dad” – thought he calls his dad “pop”. Normally, unless he speaks differently around his friends for a reason, sons and daughters stick with one form when speaking of or to their father/mother (mom,dad – pop, ma – mother, father) – I know this may seem trite, but when I read that he said “dad” a flag went off in my head and made me think about something other than your story. You don’t want that.
p.9 – instead of using a parenthetical for a (beat) say what he is doing when the beat occurs. Good place to add characterization, foreshadowing. For example, whenever Sal asks to get a beer he gets nervous because he feels like he may have a drinking problem and always rubs his arm.
“SAL
Nah, that’s OK. We got some work
lined up this afternoon.
(massaging wrist)
Wanna go for a beer later?”
-He may not have a problem or it may not be important to THIS story, but if you want the audience to notice something is up when he asks to go drinking, this could fit in later when a situation comes up and he has to act “cool and calm” at a particular bar…. Wow, I really went off on a tangent… sorry.
p.9 – “Behind Sal, Beck suddenly sits bolt upright” – just say, “Behind Sal, Beck bolts upright”. No need for the unnecessary wording. You get the same feeling and understanding with just “bolts upright” and it allows your story to keep flowing.
p.10 – Unless the last names are important to the story, just leave them to the main character or just a few characters. You can show importance to the reader when they see a full name opposed to a first name.
p.11 – “WALT SANDERS, 30 something and definitely a career guy” – show us how he is a career guy… scars? Old war medals line the wall from 1995 to now? – Plus wouldn’t a “career guy” have to be a bit older for that term to really set in?
p.11 – “The door opens. Light, heat, and John enter.” – how do we know “heat” enters? We can’t see this. Have to show us (e.g., beads of sweat instantly form on Sanders forehead when the door opens)
p.12 – “go” should be “goes” of
p.14 – “of” should be “off”
p.21 - “EXT. SCRAP YARD – EVENING” – just use DAY or NIGHT.
p.22 – “and sitting” should be “are sitting”… actually should be “sit” because you want to write in an active voice using present tense verbage.
p.22 – you wrote “EXT. DESERT – LATER” then in the next scene line you wrote the same thing. You need to change it… Ex: “EXT. DESERT – EVEN LATER”
p.23 – “He just” – extra space between words
p.33 – Like I mentioned before about the scene headings and slug lines you can condense your action so it flows better, especially when a character is moving quickly through different locations.
You wrote:
“EXT. HOUSE -- CONTINUOUS
John shuts the truck down and jumps out.
He runs to the house.
INT. KITCHEN -- CONTINUOUS
John bursts into the kitchen, singing at the top of his lungs
You could do this:
INT/EXT. HOUSE – CONTINUOUS
John shuts the truck down and jumps out. He runs into the
HOUSE
then bursts into the
KITCHEN
singing at the top of his lungs.
p.36 –
“TED (TO JOHN)
John, I’m just...”
-when you want a character to speak solely to another character just write (to John) in a parenthetical.
“INT. BACK ROOM, GENERAL STORE – DAY” should be “INT. GENERAL STORE, BACK ROOM – DAY”
p.62
“CONTINUOS” should be “CONTINUOUS”
p.63
“EXT. MYSTERY MINE GROUNDS – CONTINUOUS” – needs to be a scene change for other side.
p.78
What is Walt’s motivation? I’m not sure why he is so involved with what he thinks is a “waste of space” person like John in this town. He needs to have some underlying desire to be so interested in John and his friends actions.
Sal and Beck blend into each other and it’s hard to tell who’s talking when not looking at the names. You want each person to have a distinct voice and have the reader be able to figure out who is talking without even looking at the names.
p. 79
It’s taking a very long time to get things rolling. I know you are trying to integrate the subplot of John and Ellie’s relationship, but I think you need to find a way to integrate this interaction within the main plot of the story as it continues to move it forward.
p.80
Ellie says “2” and “1”. These need to be written out as “two” and “one”.
p.85
I thought Clarence asked what Art was reading and he was told that it was about rockets. I don’t recall Art even telling him about the project, so how would Clarence know this?
p.86
Walt’s dialogue needs (MORE) above it and (cont'd) to be capitalized since his speech starts on the previous page.
p.99
“They army” should be “The army”
Needs a few more turning points along the way to keep the interest going. Between p.35 and p.60, I feel like it dragged a bit and was losing luster. It took awhile to get to the point of making the Rocket 78.
Very nice ending and the tying together of both the subplot and plot. Well done.
--------------------
Here a few extra things and some final thoughts (just my opinion):
A lot of telling in your description and not showing the reader/viewer the emotions the characters feel and express. Need to be creative and figure out a way a character shows they are embarrassed or show that they are dubios… Facial expressions? Body gestures? etc.
You definitely are far ahead of most writers I have to critique on here. It flowed with a nice rhythm and pace. You have a good grasp on the structure on creating a story using the proper format. You could tighten up a lot of your scenes to get to the point faster(where most writers on here have no points in many of their scenes).
At times the story seemed to drag especially around pages 70-90. I feel like it was going smooth and pacing along nicely and then when the car was ready for action, the story slowed to halt, then dragged for twenty pages until about page 91.
Overall, I can tell you are an advanced writer with a good sense of how to properly tell a story. Congratulations on this and I think with a revision utilizing subtext in the dialogue, showing rather than telling, and tightening up a few scenes, this is a good marketable low-budget script. Good job!
read
-
In the beginning, I was planning on watching a short film that was horrifying in that it would show gross and freaky images. I am glad that this short did not do such a thing.
Halfway through the film I was searching for a meaning and what it was all about, but rather I found myself feeling emotions and getting angry or upset, and then feeling eleviated of this stress during...
In the beginning, I was planning on watching a short film that was horrifying in that it would show gross and freaky images. I am glad that this short did not do such a thing.
Halfway through the film I was searching for a meaning and what it was all about, but rather I found myself feeling emotions and getting angry or upset, and then feeling eleviated of this stress during the enlightened music and tree scene. Then it cut right back into the gore and stress.
I feel like this was better than searching for a meaning in the film. I'm glad I stopped and just let myself feel the emotions and it was quite intense.
Artsy, Abstract, and downright cool.
read
-
This is definitely one of the better screenplays I've read on here. I'll do my best to help you out and give you some advice. I'll start with a few grammatical errors that easy fixes. Your structure and format was very good and didn't really cause a problem.
p.35 - When the three walk in it should read "Russo, Crawford, and Audrey"
p. 52 - you wrote "tyre tracks" - should...
This is definitely one of the better screenplays I've read on here. I'll do my best to help you out and give you some advice. I'll start with a few grammatical errors that easy fixes. Your structure and format was very good and didn't really cause a problem.
p.35 - When the three walk in it should read "Russo, Crawford, and Audrey"
p. 52 - you wrote "tyre tracks" - should be "tire tracks". You spell tire wrong later on in your screenplay as well.
p. 93 - "pore" should be "pour"
One other thing would the underlining in ur script. It was really distraction and I don't think you should do this very much. Honestly, I don't really feel like you should underline anything in a screenplay. If it is important, let us know a different way other than underlining. Also, if it's important we should be able to detect this as a reader.
Now onto your actual screenplay.
I think this was a pretty original concept and idea. It was reminiscent of the film "Mr. Brooks".
I think you took an interesting and unique idea but went down an unoriginal path. What I mean is, is that it followed the path of every other crime movie. I would have liked you to go down some different routes and explore things that haven't been done before.
Many characters in your screenplay sound alike. Try and give them each a more distinct voice. By about the middle of a screenplay you should be able (as a reader) to distiguish dialogue between characters without having to look at their names. I couldn't do this here.
Some Scene Comments:
on p. 53 - after the father/daughter moment, I think she should start to walk to her room with the beer in her hand and then Russo stops her and takes the beer away. REASON: this will show that he let her be grown up for a little while they talked, but resorted back to the father figure in her life when she left on her own back to her room.
when russo explains to kim how he found his wife killing somebody... show us this! Have him start talking and then flashback to the actual scene. It's much more exciting to see the actual events than just hear a story on screen.
I don't really think Russo would smile when He sees the crowd slowly change feelings at the memorial hall. Lance has a knife to Kim's throat...
Overall I think this was a really interesting read and I got excited about it after the first few pages. There was one letdown and it was the end. I don't want to say it was bad or anything because it wasn't. It was good but very obvious and done before. I feel like a story original like this calls for more than that.
read
+ more reviews