Technically good, but...
I think cinematography is professional. I also give credit for using many locations. That way viewers won't feel claustrophobic. Beyond that, I do not have anything positive to say. Firstly, I didn't catch narration because of the accent, which of course is no fault of filmmaker. Yes, subtitles are necessary, unless it were BBC accent which the world is familiar with. Secondly, there is too much violence, too much killing, in such a short space of screen time, I felt rather disgusted. It looks gratuitous. Thirdly, even as a "silent" movie to me, I saw no story. Maybe I should watch and re-watch to understand it. But then, no audience in the world give a movie a second or a third or a...chance. They either enjoy it or they don't. If they find it engaging, they may watch it again. But if they don't like or don't understand it, they will never view it again.
Other Reviews by minsy 9
A review of The Boy Who Lost His Songby minsy on 09/14/2008For a black and white film, the cinematography and the post production effects are good. However, after viewing twice, I still didn't understand what the story is. This compares poorly to standard silent b & w films from Hollywood, which are so easy to understand, even a child knows what's going on first time round, helped by the dialogue displayed and easy-to-understand... read
A review of Parallelsby minsy on 10/12/2007I simply loved the cinematography - the image sharpness and the lighting were really great for my eyes. I also enjoyed the subject matter and the way it is presented - intercutting views from 2 real deserters from 2 wars. However, there is one big drawback. I felt frustrated there weren't any footages from the 2 wars, only a couple of stills, to support these guys' claims,... read
A review of The Fortunate Sonby minsy on 10/12/2007Good cinematography, music, cutting and acting. It makes a very effective, emotionally-charged scene from a movie. But in terms of enthralling me with a gripping story - with its twists and turns - it failed. The story needs expanding a little. I can't help feeling that people who make one-scene shorts do it because cost is their main consideration. Telling an engaging story... read