Review of: Henry's dilemmas....The Switch 

reviewed by mwiings on 11/06/2011
Credited Review
mwiings
The Switch Credited Review
While I believe I understood what you were trying to achieve with this story I find that its a little too detached and I find myself struggling to bond with the characters but I am not sure if that is due to the genre (that I do not read often) or the fact that there does not seem to be a lot of depth to the characters or their relationships.

Your opening scene has a few inconsistencies which throw me off. You mention Vi before Henry and I assume they must be co-conspirators in something but it turns out his wife is just sitting in on questioning. Is this normal practise when a spouse isn’t implicated in something (because of how she is thrown out I assume she isn’t involved in any of Henry’s activities)? Then Vi asks him how he could do “this” to her and defends him to the police in the same breath, this makes it hard for me to feel anything towards her because this is too erratic to be quirky. When he steals the ledgers he takes Vi with him and I find myself asking why when she obviously would be a bad choice. At this point I don’t know if he’s a buffoon caught up in a life he really didn’t want or a simply bad ‘stupid’ person. You mention he was threatened but people who have the fear of death in them could have asked for help and that would have involved getting a policeperson to go with them to get the ledgers I imagine.

Like I said though, I find myself struggling to review this story because I think you are trying to deliver a quirky tale of a buffoon who simply ‘doesn’t know any better’ but I cannot be sure. If I have missed the point of your story then that is my fault and you can disregard this review, if you do make any changes to developing your characters or re-writing it I am sure it would be a lot cleaner.

Other Reviews by mwiings 32

  • A review of Thy Will Be Done
    by mwiings on 02/22/2013
    When I first started reading this I was a little thrown by the voice and I even pulled out my pen to start making corrections and page one and two suffered however, once I reached page three I "got it" and there isnt a mark after "when?" and I must say I am a fan and it ended too early. This was very well executed and the only correction I feel you should make is on page two... read
  • by mwiings on 02/21/2013
    This story was brief and had punch. An enjoyable read overall. I did pause on the first sentence over the use of the word “stood” in that context but I believe it makes the scene more “statuesque” and on my second read it fit a lot better and I wasn’t jarred out of the scene. I do think that Foster would have been better served with more description on him as a person and... read
  • A review of Das Leben Dieb
    by mwiings on 12/11/2011
    I simply love this story. I am a fan of faery tales and this is a wonderful way of weaving it into a modern “story” without losing its tale-like quality. As I love it so much there are only 2 things I can think of to improve it. Your imagery is very strong and there was only one scene that didn’t work for me: in the beginning when Bill strokes his wife’s tummy she hums to... read
+ more reviews