Review of: Not My Secret to Tell 

reviewed by vieira4 on 04/14/2012
Credited Review
vieira4
Very good, compelling story. Credited Review
Time flew by while I was reading this. You have a real gift for keeping the reader engaged. I take it the couple had decided to kill Mr Hunt? That's what I took from the mildly ambiguous ending. If that's what you meant, it doesn't require clarification.

I saw one mistake; on page 9, you wrote 'Denny' instead of Danny. I'm sure you've noticed, so don't worry about re-uploading just for that, and losing all your reviews (I always notice a dumb mistake after adding credits to a story).

At the beginning, the way I read the text was that Betsy and the diner owner, not Betsy and Danny, had been high school sweethearts. I didn't figure out the truth until near the end. This could be tidied up just a little, to be 100% clear. Otherwise, this story is impeccably told. Well done.

Other Reviews by vieira4 80

  • A review of Rafter J Ranching
    by vieira4 on 06/11/2013
    Hi. I know nothing about farms, tractors and cows, but I enjoyed this tale: by the end, I was really into it, wanting to know what would happen to the rancher next. Highlights: I like having 'Ed' at the start of every sentence about him: I like the rhythm this creates. I also liked the juxtaposition between his slowness and his apparent rashness when irritated. I laughed at... read
  • by vieira4 on 06/10/2013
    Thanks for sharing 'Smarter Than A Smartphone'. I thoroughly enjoyed this - very much a zeitgeist piece. Mr Walker initially appears to be a conniving, lazy character attempting to gain maximum reward for minimum effort, but over time, the true extent of his genius becomes clear. I love the conclusion - I was expecting the protagonist to succeed, but I wasn't expecting him... read
  • A review of The Rebellious Son
    by vieira4 on 06/08/2013
    I really liked this story. I worked out what the creature was on about page 2, which was the perfect length of time as far as I am concerned. I don't like obvious stories, and I don't like those that feel as if they have been written for an intellectual elite. You obviously researched this well and know a lot about mediaeval myths. I know absolutely nothing about any of this,... read
+ more reviews