Well Intentioned But Stupid
An eight year old bank robber? That's just plain dumb. And even if it is meant as satire against the deplorable consequences of lack of education, it's just plain dumb. There are a lot better ways to satirize the effects of poor education or a failing education system. Furthermore, watching en eight year old put a gun to someone's head is disgusting. This comes from the mind of one crass and repugnant individual. It's sad, too, because she's a decent actress and cute enough to catch someone's attention. Finally, the transitions do not work at all. Film is about an illusion, and watching the digits on the cuts destroys that illusion, not to mention looks awful.
Other Reviews by ScreenwriterX 17
A review of Spare Changeby ScreenwriterX on 03/19/2004I'm sorry about the messed up title, but I couldn't resist. Seriously, this short is quite good. I'm guessing you're from the "leave them wanting more" school of thought. You definitely achieved this goal with me. In fact, throughout most of the film I'm zoomed in waiting to see things unfold; it really keeps the audience's attention. The theme of shallow people avoiding their... read
A review of Final Thoughtsby ScreenwriterX on 02/16/2004There's definitely a lack of logic and coherence in this short. The story just doesn't come together. Most people have seen dozens of war movies, so you have to take that into consideration. Which war is this? Is the soldier an American soldier? How did he come to be abandoned? Would he really hope to get shot after a few days alone in the woods? Would he really give up so... read
A review of Gonna Make It?by ScreenwriterX on 02/06/2004This short was sort of amusing. I gather from the production notes that the take is one of questioning the student. This seems contradictory to the story. The character doesn't do anything to alienate the audience or to win the audience. He's just sort of neutral. But the things that happen to him seem a bit cruel. The guy rooting against him, the cruel sign on the door, and... read